<?xml version="1.0"?>
<law><site_title>Virginia Decoded</site_title><site_url>https://vacode.org</site_url><law_id>71003</law_id><section_number>15.2-1636.9</section_number><catch_line>Appeal from decision of Board</catch_line><edition url="https://vacode.org/2025/" slug="2025" current="TRUE" last_updated="">2025</edition><referred_to_by><reference>15.2-1636.10</reference><reference>15.2-2507</reference><reference>2.2-612</reference></referred_to_by><structure><unit label="title" level="1" order_by="1" identifier="15.2">Counties, Cities and Towns</unit><unit label="subtitle" level="2" order_by="1" identifier="II">Powers of Local Government</unit><unit label="chapter" level="3" order_by="1" identifier="16">Local Constitutional Officers, Courthouses and Supplies</unit><unit label="article" level="4" order_by="1" identifier="6.1">Compensation Board Generally</unit></structure><text>
						<section id="A"><p><span class="prefix-number">A.</span> Any officer whose budget is affected by a decision of the Board under this article made for the fiscal year pursuant to and at the time designated by &#xA7;&#xA7; <a class="law" title="Filing requests for salaries" href="/15.2-1636.7/">15.2-1636.7</a> and <a class="law" title="Duties of Board in fixing salaries, expenses, etc" href="/15.2-1636.8/">15.2-1636.8</a> and no other, or any <span class="dictionary">county</span> or <span class="dictionary">city</span> affected thereby, or the <span class="dictionary">Attorney General</span> as representative of the Commonwealth, shall have the right to <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> from any such decision of the Board, within forty-five days from the date of such decision. Such <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> shall lie to the <span class="dictionary">circuit</span> <span class="dictionary">court</span> of the <span class="dictionary">county</span> or <span class="dictionary">city</span> wherein the officer making the <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> resides. The <span class="dictionary">court</span> shall be presided over by three <span class="dictionary">judges</span> of <span class="dictionary">circuit</span> <span class="dictionary">courts</span> remote from that to which the <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> is taken. The three <span class="dictionary">judges</span> shall be chosen by the Chief Justice of the Supreme <span class="dictionary">Court</span> from a <span class="dictionary">panel</span> of fifteen active or retired <span class="dictionary">judges</span> selected to hear such matters by the Supreme <span class="dictionary">Court</span>. Such <span class="dictionary">judges</span> shall remain on the <span class="dictionary">panel</span> for a period of time determined by the Chief Justice of the Supreme <span class="dictionary">Court</span>. No <span class="dictionary">judge</span> may be appointed to hear an <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> involving a <span class="dictionary">jurisdiction</span> in his current or former <span class="dictionary">circuit</span>. Notice of such <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> shall be given within the time above specified by any such officer to the Compensation Board, the <span class="dictionary">county</span> or <span class="dictionary">city</span> affected and the <span class="dictionary">Attorney General</span>. The officer appealing shall, in the <span class="dictionary">appeal</span>, state with specificity what action of the Compensation Board the officer is contesting, the additional services provided to the <span class="dictionary">locality</span> not required by <span class="dictionary">law</span>, and the cost of providing such service. The Compensation Board shall notify the Chief Justice forthwith when all administrative remedies have been exhausted by the <span class="dictionary">appellant</span> and the three-<span class="dictionary">judge</span> <span class="dictionary">court</span> shall be designated upon receipt of the notice by the Chief Justice. The <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> shall be heard within forty-five days from the date such notice is filed by the Board with the Chief Justice. At least fifteen days&#x2019; notice of the time and place set for the <span class="dictionary">hearing</span> shall be given the officer noting such <span class="dictionary">appeal</span>, the <span class="dictionary">county</span> or <span class="dictionary">city</span> affected, the Compensation Board and the <span class="dictionary">Attorney General</span>. On such <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> all questions involved in said decision shall be heard <span class="dictionary">de novo</span> by the <span class="dictionary">court</span> and its decision on all questions shall be certified by the clerk thereof to the officer affected, to the <span class="dictionary">locality</span> and to the chairman of the Compensation Board.
			In making its decision, the <span class="dictionary">court</span> shall give consideration to the amount of funds budgeted and expended by the <span class="dictionary">local government</span> for the <span class="dictionary">constitutional officer</span> which exceeds the amount reimbursed by the Compensation Board, the extent to which the officer provides additional services to the <span class="dictionary">locality</span> not required by <span class="dictionary">law</span> and to what extent, if any, the <span class="dictionary">local government</span> should participate in providing the additional funding requested by the <span class="dictionary">constitutional officer</span>. The <span class="dictionary">court</span> shall also give consideration both to the officer&#x2019;s ability to perform his statutory duties without additional funding and the ability of the Compensation Board and <span class="dictionary">local government</span> to provide additional funding for the officer&#x2019;s functions. The <span class="dictionary">court</span> shall also consider maximum staffing and funding levels set in the general appropriation act and any other statutory provisions which would otherwise prohibit the Compensation Board from granting the officer&#x2019;s request. The burden of proving the necessity of additional funding shall be borne by the officer. After due consideration of Compensation Board and <span class="dictionary">local government</span> statutory authority and the <span class="dictionary">constitutional officer</span>&#x2019;s demonstrated need for additional funding, the <span class="dictionary">court</span> shall determine the extent to which the Compensation Board and <span class="dictionary">local government</span> shall share in the additional funding. Should the <span class="dictionary">court</span> determine that additional funding is necessary for the officer to perform his duties, and that it is the responsibility of the Compensation Board to provide all or part of the additional funds, and that the Compensation Board does not have the ability to provide such additional funding, the Compensation Board shall request the necessary additional funding from the General Assembly at its next occurring regular session.
			Should the <span class="dictionary">court</span> determine that additional funding is necessary for the officer to perform his duties and that it is the responsibility of the <span class="dictionary">local government</span> to provide all or part of the additional funds, and that the <span class="dictionary">local government</span> does not have the ability to provide such additional funding, the chief administrative officer of the <span class="dictionary">local government</span> shall include such request in the budget submission to the local <span class="dictionary">governing body</span>.
			From the decision of the <span class="dictionary">court</span> there shall be no right of further <span class="dictionary">appeal</span>. The decision of the <span class="dictionary">court</span> shall be within the difference between the amounts originally requested by the appealing officer pursuant to &#xA7; <a class="law" title="Filing requests for salaries" href="/15.2-1636.7/">15.2-1636.7</a> and the amounts fixed by the Compensation Board for such fiscal year; however, when the <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> is filed by a <span class="dictionary">county</span> or <span class="dictionary">city</span> such decision shall be within the difference between the prior salaries, expenses and other allowances of such officer and the amounts fixed by the Compensation Board for such fiscal year. In the event an <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> is filed by both the officer affected and the <span class="dictionary">county</span> or <span class="dictionary">city</span> affected, such decision shall be within the difference between the amounts originally requested by the appealing officer pursuant to &#xA7; <a class="law" title="Filing requests for salaries" href="/15.2-1636.7/">15.2-1636.7</a> and the prior salaries, expenses and other allowances of such officer.
			In pursuing the provisions of this section, <span class="dictionary">constitutional officers</span> may use funds designated by the Compensation Board or appropriated by their local <span class="dictionary">governing body</span> to employ independent <span class="dictionary">counsel</span>, provided that funds have been specifically appropriated for such purpose. <a id="paragraph-256023" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/15.2-1636.9/#A"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="B"><p><span class="prefix-number">B.</span> Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection A, no <span class="dictionary">appeal</span> of any decision of the Board shall lie to the <span class="dictionary">circuit</span> <span class="dictionary">court</span> from the date of enactment of this subsection until July 1, 1993, at which time the <span class="dictionary">circuit</span> <span class="dictionary">court</span> may consider <span class="dictionary">appeals</span> for all fiscal years affected by this moratorium and for subsequent fiscal years. <a id="paragraph-256024" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/15.2-1636.9/#B"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section></text><history>Code 1950, &#xA7; 14-65; 1964, c. 386, &#xA7; 14.1-52; 1971, Ex. Sess., c. 156; 1972, c. 390; 1974, c. 465; 1976, c. 673; 1977, c. 80; 1980, c. 588; 1983, c. 382; 1991, c. 617; 1992, c. 342; 1993, cc. 554, 563; 1995, c. 733; 1998, c. 872.</history><metadata></metadata></law>
