<?xml version="1.0"?>
<law><site_title>Virginia Decoded</site_title><site_url>https://vacode.org</site_url><law_id>55844</law_id><section_number>56-235.5</section_number><catch_line>Telephone regulatory alternatives</catch_line><edition url="https://vacode.org/2025/" slug="2025" current="TRUE" last_updated="">2025</edition><referred_to_by><reference>56-481.2</reference><reference>56-54.2</reference><reference>56-57</reference></referred_to_by><structure><unit label="title" level="1" order_by="1" identifier="56">Public Service Companies</unit><unit label="chapter" level="2" order_by="1" identifier="10">Heat, Light, Power, Water and Other Utility Companies Generally</unit><unit label="article" level="3" order_by="1" identifier="2">Services, Rates, Charges, Etc</unit></structure><text>
						<section id="A"><p><span class="prefix-number">A.</span> As used in this section, &#x201C;<span class="dictionary">telephone company</span>&#x201D; means any <span class="dictionary">public service corporation</span> or <span class="dictionary">public service company</span> which holds a certificate of public convenience and necessity to furnish <span class="dictionary">local exchange telephone service</span>, except that companies which are regulated pursuant to Chapter 16 (&#xA7; <a class="law" title="Short title" href="/56-485/">56-485</a> et seq.) or 19 (&#xA7; <a class="law" title="Definitions" href="/56-531/">56-531</a> et seq.) of this title are not included within this definition. <a id="paragraph-204581" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#A"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="B"><p><span class="prefix-number">B.</span> In regulating telephone services of any <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span>, and notwithstanding any provision of <span class="dictionary">law</span> to the contrary, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span>, after giving notice and an opportunity for <span class="dictionary">hearing</span>, may replace the ratemaking methodology set forth in &#xA7; <a class="law" title="All rates, tolls, etc., to be just and reasonable to jurisdictional customers; findings and conclusions to be set forth; alternative forms of regulation for electric companies" href="/56-235.2/">56-235.2</a> with any alternative form of regulation which: (i) protects the affordability of basic <span class="dictionary">local exchange telephone service</span>, as such service is defined by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span>; (ii) reasonably ensures the continuation of quality <span class="dictionary">local exchange telephone service</span>; (iii) will not unreasonably prejudice or disadvantage any class of <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span> customers or other providers of competitive services; and (iv) is in the public interest. Alternatives may differ among telephone companies and may include, but are not limited to, the use of price regulation, ranges of authorized returns, categories of services, price indexing or other alternative forms of regulation. A <span class="dictionary">hearing</span> under this section shall include the right to present <span class="dictionary">evidence</span> and be heard. Prior to any <span class="dictionary">hearing</span> under this section, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall provide parties an opportunity to conduct <span class="dictionary">discovery</span>. <a id="paragraph-204582" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#B"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="C"><p><span class="prefix-number">C.</span> Any <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span> or company regulated pursuant to Chapter 16 (&#xA7;&#xA0;<a class="law" title="Short title" href="/56-485/">56-485</a> et seq.) or 19 (&#xA7;&#xA0;<a class="law" title="Definitions" href="/56-531/">56-531</a> et seq.) of this title may apply to the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> at any time to obtain an alternative form of regulation. The <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall approve the application if it finds, after notice to all affected parties and <span class="dictionary">hearing</span>, that the proposal meets the standards for an alternative form of regulation set forth in subsection B. <a id="paragraph-204583" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#C"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="C1" class="indent-1"><p><span class="prefix-number">1.</span> A <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> <span class="dictionary">order</span>, including appropriate <span class="dictionary">findings</span> of <span class="dictionary">fact</span> and conclusions of <span class="dictionary">law</span>, denying or approving, with or without modification, an application for an alternative form of regulation shall be entered no more than 90 days from the filing of the application, except that the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span>, upon notice to all parties in interest, may extend that period in additional 30-day increments not to exceed an additional 90 days in all. <a id="paragraph-204584" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#C1"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="C2" class="indent-1"><p><span class="prefix-number">2.</span> If the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> approves the application with modifications, the <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span>, or company regulated pursuant to Chapter 16 (&#xA7; <a class="law" title="Short title" href="/56-485/">56-485</a> et seq.) or 19 (&#xA7; <a class="law" title="Definitions" href="/56-531/">56-531</a> et seq.) of this title, may, at its option, withdraw its application and continue to be regulated under the form of regulation that existed immediately prior to the filing of the application, unless it is modified for a <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span> by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> pursuant to subsection B. <a id="paragraph-204585" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#C2"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="D"><p><span class="prefix-number">D.</span> The <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> may, after notice and opportunity for <span class="dictionary">hearing</span>, alter, <span class="dictionary">amend</span> or revoke any alternative form of regulation previously implemented if it finds that (i) the affordability of basic local exchange service, as such service is defined by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span>, is threatened by the alternative form of regulation; (ii) the quality of <span class="dictionary">local exchange telephone service</span> has deteriorated or will deteriorate to the point that the public interest will not be served by continuation of the alternative form of regulation; (iii) the terms ordered by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> in connection with approval of a company&#x2019;s application for alternative form of regulation have been violated; (iv) any class of <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span> customers or other providers of competitive services are being unreasonably prejudiced or disadvantaged by the alternative form of regulation; or (v) the alternative form of regulation is no longer in the public interest. <a id="paragraph-204586" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#D"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="E"><p><span class="prefix-number">E.</span> The <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall have the authority, after notice to all affected parties and an opportunity for <span class="dictionary">hearing</span>, to determine whether any telephone service of a <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span> is subject to competition and to provide, either by rule or case-by-case determination, for deregulation, detariffing, or modified regulation determined by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> to be in the public interest for such competitive services. <a id="paragraph-204587" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#E"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="F"><p><span class="prefix-number">F.</span> The <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> may determine telephone services of any <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span> to be competitive when it finds competition or the potential for competition in the market place is or can be an effective regulator of the price of those services. Such determination may be made by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> on a statewide or a more limited geographic basis, such as one or more political subdivisions or one or more telephone exchange areas, or on the basis of a category of customers, such as business or residential customers, or customers exceeding a revenue or service quantity threshold, or some combination thereof. The <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> may also determine bundles composed of a combination of competitive and noncompetitive services to be competitive if the noncompetitive services are available separately pursuant to tariff or otherwise. In determining whether competition effectively regulates the prices of services, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall consider: (i) the ease of market entry, (ii) the presence of other providers reasonably meeting the needs of consumers, and (iii) other factors the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> considers relevant. For purposes of this section, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall consider all wireless communications providers that offer voice communications services to be facilities-based competitors owning wireline network facilities and reasonably meeting the needs of consumers, regardless of whether such wireless providers own wireline network facilities. In its determination, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall not exclude as a competitor any affiliate of the <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span>. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this subsection, any telephone services that are the functional equivalent of the services offered individually or as part of a bundle of services by a county, city or town pursuant to &#xA7; <a class="law" title="Certificate to operate as a telephone utility" href="/56-265.4_4/">56-265.4:4</a> or Article 5.1 (&#xA7; <a class="law" title="Offering of communications services" href="/56-484.7_1/">56-484.7:1</a> et seq.) of Chapter 15 of this title, either directly or pursuant to a public-private partnership, shall be deemed competitive services in the geographic area where the services of the county, city or town are offered for purposes of this article and any alternate regulatory plans approved by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span>. <a id="paragraph-204588" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#F"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="G"><p><span class="prefix-number">G.</span> The <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall monitor the competitiveness of any telephone service previously found by it to be competitive under any provision of subsection F above and may change that conclusion, if, after notice and an opportunity for <span class="dictionary">hearing</span>, it finds that competition no longer effectively regulates the price of that service. <a id="paragraph-204589" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#G"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="H"><p><span class="prefix-number">H.</span> Whenever the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> adopts an alternative form of regulation pursuant to subsection B or C above, or determines that a service is competitive pursuant to subsections E and F above, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall adopt safeguards to protect consumers and competitive markets. At a minimum these safeguards must ensure that there is no cross subsidization of competitive services by monopoly services. <a id="paragraph-204590" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#H"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="I"><p><span class="prefix-number">I.</span> If the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> determines pursuant to subsections E and F that 75 percent or more of residential households or businesses in a <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span>&#x2019;s incumbent territory are in areas that have been determined by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> to be competitive for a telephone service, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall expand, for that telephone service throughout the company&#x2019;s incumbent territory, its competitive determination and apply the same regulatory treatment already adopted by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> for that telephone service in competitive areas, including any safeguards under subsection H. <a id="paragraph-204591" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#I"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section>
						<section id="J"><p><span class="prefix-number">J.</span> If a <span class="dictionary">telephone company</span> provides 90 percent or more of its residential and business lines access to fiber optic or copper-based broadband service, as defined by the Federal Communications <span class="dictionary">Commission</span>, within an exchange area, the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> shall expand, for basic and associated telephone services in that exchange area, its competitive determination and apply the same regulatory treatment already adopted by the <span class="dictionary">Commission</span> for those services in competitive areas, including any safeguards under subsection H. <a id="paragraph-204592" class="section-permalink" href="https://vacode.org/56-235.5/#J"><i class="fa fa-link"/></a></p></section></text><history>1993, c. 21; 1996, c. 18; 2002, cc. 479, 489; 2003, c. 711; 2009, c. 788.</history><metadata></metadata></law>
